Sales Tax is Changing. What’s happening & why? Client Service Opportunities
Andy Johnson CPA- Partner Peisner & Johnson Mike Fleming – Peisner Johnson Ray Bigley -VP Bus Developemnet June 27, 2013 NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION CONFIDENTIAL © Copyright Avalara, 2013
1
Today’s Discussion
Market Forces & Evolving Markets Market Place Fairness Act (67 to 29) Peisner Johnson - Client Services
Market Forces
$107,000,000,000 $55,000,000,000
Market Forces: State Budget Gap
State Budget Gaps
Market Forces: State Budget Gap
$23,800,000,000 $12,500,000,000
Market Forces: State Budget Gap
Market Forces
Kentucky 1930 46 States, WA DC & Guam
11,000 + Taxing Jurisdictions
Evolving Markets Mobile payments (Affirm, Square, GoPayment, Fortumo, Zong)
Gaming (Mobile Phone, Xbox, PlayStation, Wii)
Omni channel Markets: Mobile
12
Omni channel Markets: Gaming
14
Omni channel Markets: Gaming
Next up after Marketplace Fairness ?
Digital Goods – MP3 Files, Movie / TV downloads, Purchased Image, etc. Virtual Items – Exist within a specified environment. Example -Xbox Live marketplace, MapleStory: Flower bouquets, Game’s weapons Sheldon’s dilemma from the Big Bang Theory 15
Revenue Shortfalls Combined with Changes in Commerce Create Market Inflection Points…
Marketplace Fairness Act (67 to 29)
Marketplace Fairness Acts – Grants authority to states to require a remote retailer to collect sales tax
– Defines a remote retailer as any seller who makes interstate sales of products or services – Effectively eliminates nexus for sales tax purposes – Applies only to remote retailers with annual remote sales in excess of $1 million, but remote sales includes exempt sales – Requires very little simplification from states, and most of that is only for remote retailers
18
AUTOMATED RETURNS It’s not a laughing matter
Peisner Johnson & Company, LLP Andrew Johnson & Michael Fleming
20
Michael J. Fleming
@MikeAtPJCo
I Have Nexus. Now What?
Agenda
• Webinar will last one hour • One hour CPE credit available • Ask a question any time
Who Are We? • • • • •
Founded in 1992 Registered CPA firm State & local taxes only Former state auditors & other professionals Consult in all states & Canada
Poll Question
Andrew H. Johnson, CPA
@AndyJohnsonCPA
What is nexus? Nexus: A connection; a link or tie Minimum level of physical presence that allows a jurisdiction to require you to register, collect, and remit sales and use tax
Let's Go to Court
Court Cases • •
Scripto Georgia company used independent sales reps in Florida, and Supreme Court held that it had significant connection (1960)
National Bellas Hess 1967 Supreme Court Case. National Bellas Hess, Inc. v. Department of Revenue of Ill., 87 S.Ct. 1389 (1967)
Court Cases •
•
Tyler Pipe Texas company with no property, offices, or employees in Washington. Supreme Court agreed that activities created nexus and assessment stood (1987) Quill Corporation For sales and use tax purposes, the Supreme Court held that a taxpayer must have a physical presence in the state. Quill Corporation v. North Dakota, 112 S.Ct. 1912
Obvious • Buildings, property
• Employees
Less Obvious • Independent sales reps • Sub-contractors, agents • Installation, training, maintenance • Rented or leased property
Nexus-Creating Activities
I have nexus. Now what? Generally:
• •
Register Collect the sales tax/pay the income tax o Collect a proper resale certificate in lieu of tax
•
File regular tax returns
How do states find you? • •
Auditing your customers Information sharing with other states
•
Special task forces
•
Leads o Former employees o Competitors
The state already suspects you.
•
Questions identify: o Assets in the state o Activities in the state
•
Response deadline
•
Penalties of perjury
Nexus Questionnaires
Questionnaire Verbiage Alabama "I declare that the information furnished in response to this questionnaire is to the best of my knowledge and belief, true, correct and complete.”
Michigan “I declare, under penalty of perjury, that the information provided in this questionnaire and any attachments is, to the best of my knowledge, true, correct and complete. If prepared by a person other than officer, partner or owner of the business, this declaration is based on all information you have knowledge.”
Questionnaire Verbiage Texas "I declare that the information in this document and any attachment is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.”
Michigan “Under penalties of perjury, I declare that the information furnished in this questionnaire is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true, correct and complete. If prepared by a person other than an officer of this corporation, this declaration is based on all information of which you have knowledge.”
•
Don’t respond o Issue preliminary assessment
•
Respond o Could impact your voluntary disclosure o Contact a consultant
Nexus Questionnaires
If the State Finds You • • •
No statute of limitations Seven or more years of tax assessments Penalties and interest o Up to 60%
Poll Question
THE PROBLEM NEVER GOES AWAY…
IT ONLY GETS
BIGGER
Case Studies
• Small company in a couple of states • Got national contract • Used subcontractors to do local work • Audited and assessed • Registered in all states
Service Company
•
• • • •
Specialized software
Traveled to customer sites to install and train Nexus questionnaire completed and returned States requested prior seven years returns $300,000 liability +
Software Company
• • •
•
Largest client requested tax be charged Register in every state Set up the billing systems with correct rates and taxability
Registered in all states
Bank Bag Company
• • •
Purchaser conducted due diligence Determined they had nexus in states where they were not registered Purchaser requested they either discount price of business for amount owed or place funds in trust until resolved.
Sale of Company
Poll Question
The Biggest Tragedy in Sales Tax
Tax you could have collected (willingly) from your customer at the time of the transaction ends up coming out of your pocket three years later… With Penalties and Interest!
THE PROBLEM NEVER GOES AWAY…
IT ONLY GETS
BIGGER
Define the Problem •
What states am I registered in now?
•
Where else do I have nexus?
•
What do I sell in those states?
Quantify the Problem • • • •
Sales Purchases
Net Income Apportionment
Potential Refund? • • • •
Sales Purchases
Net Income Apportionment
Fix the Problem •
•
Rank your states by potential liability
Possible approaches o Do nothing o Register o Amnesty o Voluntary disclosure agreement (VDA)
Problems with Registering Now When did you first start doing business in our state?
•
All back taxes returns due
o Back to day one
•
Penalty and interest applies
State Amnesty • •
Take advantage of state amnesties Amnesties are rare
Voluntary Disclosure Agreement •
Request an agreement on a no-name basis o Limited look back period o Eliminate or reduce penalty and interest
•
Registration is part of the process Not available in certain circumstances
Voluntary Disclosure Agreement •
Deadline o Critical; extensions possible
•
Time frame o Calculate the tax o Complete the forms necessary o Send forms & money in on time
•
Now What? Set up your systems to bill and collect the proper sales tax rates
•
File sales tax returns
•
Remit tax Relax.
Sales Tax Returns • •
Monthly, quarterly, annually, depending on sales volume Local jurisdictions
o e.g. AZ, CO, LA
•
Stay current on rate changes
Costly Mistakes • • •
•
Ignoring the situation Failing to collect tax at the time of sale Registering without a VDA in place
Remitting tax to the wrong jurisdiction
Summary 1.Define the Problem
1.Quantify the Problem
PeisnerJohnson.com Webinars SALTsource newsletter Blog Charts and white papers
How Can We Help You? State tax refund reviews State tax audit defense • Text Nexus determination and mitigation
Compliance services
CPE Credit
• GoTo Webinar control panel • Follow up email
Webinar Survey
Avalara – Corporate Snapshot Market Leader in Automated Sales & Use Tax • 10,000 customers 60,000 registered users • 3+ million calculations per day – 1 billion annually • Manage 5 million exemption certificates & file 500,000 returns • Filing & remitting $14 billion in sales & use tax annually Enviable Business Position: A Growing Company in a Growing Market – Not a zero sum market • Acquisitions of CertCapture, Tax Matrix & additional taxability content Additional Content is a market changing event • Sales Tax in the News – NPR, Amazon proposals– related to eCommerce, Market Street Fairness Act • Expanding Markets – gaming, mobile payment platforms • New Datacenters – To address Growth & Market expansion
Summary & Questions
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]