political models

POLITICAL MODELS

Heartland-Rimland Model







In 1904, British geographer Halford Mackinder proposed what would become known as the Heartland-Rimland model It was an effort to define the global geopolitical landscape and determine areas of potential future conflict He stated that agricultural land was the primary commodity that states were interested in







The Heartland was the Eastern European Steppe, a very productive area of grain agriculture mostly controlled by the Russian Empire at that time & the mineral and timber rich region across the Urals into Siberia It was this portion of the Earth’s surface that boarding Rimland states such as the German Empire, the AustroHungarian Empire and Romania were potential invaders of Rimland also contained other landwolves eager to grab at neighboring territories such as France and Italy & seawolves, such as Great Britain & Japan

Predictive Power of the Model 







In effect, Mackinder accurately predicted the battle lines of the Eastern Front during WW I In 1921 he revised the model expanding the Heartland further into Central Europe From 1904 onward Mackinder points out that the areas of future conflict are the borderlines between the Heartland and the Rimland The prediction comes true again in 1931 with the invasion by the Japanese which some identify as the start of WWII

Shatterbelt Theory  







Proposed in 1950 by Saul Cohen He modified Mackinder’s Heartland into the “Pivot Area” and Rimland into the “Inner Crescent” The rest of the world became the Outer Crescent including the US His concept was that the Cold War conflicts would likely occur within the Inner Crescent He pointed out several Inner Crescent areas of geopolitical weakness he called Shatterbelts

Containment Theory 







Conflict areas like the Soviet Union and China would attempt top capture to create buffer states, lands that would protect them by creating a surrounding buffer of sympathetic countries U.S. diplomat George Kennen first proposed the strategic policy of containment in 1947 He proposed the U.S. and its allies would attempt to build a containment wall around the core communist states Anytime the USSR or China attempted to expand the realm of influence politically the forces of NATO would be deployed to stop them







It was successful at first and communist movements were stopped in Greece, Iran and Malaysia However, Communist reached a military stalemate in Korea in 1953 and won military victories That along with communist takeovers in countries like Hungary, Angola, Cuba and Nicaragua were evidence their were limitations to the containment theory (communism spread to the outer cresent)





The U.S. and its allied states had to contain these soviet controlled satellite states to prevent communism from spreading They feared the domino effect where one state would fall to communism and then inspire and support communist uprisings



Despite the failings of the containment approach. Communism was limited due to the number of buffer states